PRS S2 McCarty 594 Thinline (stated 2025) — S2 tier, Pearl White (as listed)

A 2025‑stated PRS McCarty 594 in the S2 tier and thinline body format — blends vintage‑inspired scale and controls with PRS construction; priced in a sensible band by AG’s metric.

Why we selected it today

Chosen for representing the McCarty 594 family in S2 form — a model that combines vintage‑inspired scale and controls with PRS construction — and because AG’s pricing tool marks it as a Fair Price, i.e. a sensible asking level rather than a bargain. The pricing evidence helped too: AG currently rates the asking price as Fair Price against its like-for-like comparison set.

The model’s pedigree

The McCarty 594 family combines vintage‑inspired scale length and controls with PRS construction. SE, S2 and Core tiers occupy separate value bands and must be identified for accurate comparison.

How we matched this guitar

Detected identity: “PRS McCarty 594 · S2” (medium confidence). The listing states the year as 2025 and the tier as S2; these are presented as listed rather than independently verified by the site.

Key features

S2 tier McCarty 594 specification (as detected), thinline body format (as stated in the listing title) and PRS‑style control layout and construction conventions associated with the model family.

How the asking price compares

At $1,999, this sits against a current median asking price of $2,613.70 across 1 other closely matched listing. Allowing for the like-for-like asking-price history we have collected, the AG benchmark is $1,867.30. The featured guitar is about 7.1% above that level. That is why AG calls it Fair Price: it sits in sensible market territory rather than looking either obviously cheap or obviously expensive. These are observed eBay asking prices, not confirmed sold prices.

What a buyer should check

Identify the exact tier and body format, verify pickups and hardware, and inspect the neck, frets and finish.